A Place of Ice (...And Fire?)
When picturing hell, the first image that comes to mind is a fiery, scorching place of eternal torment. A place of pure agony. However, in Dante’s Inferno, the final circle of hell is ice cold. The phrase “when hell freezes over” is common;y heard, but what if hell was already frozen? In Dante’s Inferno, the ninth circle of hell is frozen instead of raging with heat like the rest of hell. Throughout the book, Virgil, our beloved poet, guides Dante through the agonizing journey through hell. They travel level after level, all fiery and scorching, full of eternal pain. Dante describes hell as “full of the cruelest punishments and pain”(Inf. 19.111) and “a sanctuary of pain”(Inf. 5. 16), which paints a grim picture. This is not a place you would want to dwell in. However, in the ninth circle, the description changes. Dante uses phrases like “terrible cold” (Inf. 32.23) and “so thick an ice veil” (Inf. 32.25) to paint hell as a frozen wasteland.
As the dynamic duo reach the heart of hell, the inhabitants are completely imprisoned in ice. Dante describes the shades as being “all covered up in ice” (Inf. 34. 10), and this brings forth an image of desolation and utter despair. To be encased in ice is to be wholly wretched. Warmth is one of the main components of life, and while these shades are obviously not physically living, their spirits continue to dwell. No semblance of true life, living or dead, can be found in them. They are shells of what they could be. Even in the fiery torment of the circles above, the sinner’s physical bodies were visible as opposed to the shadow bodies of those in the ninth circle.
We meet Satan in this circle and the constant flapping of his wings keep the atmosphere frigid. Dante says “and from his flapping raised three gales that swept / Cocytus, and reduced it all to ice.” (Inf. 34.51-52); Satan’s wings are gargantuan. In order to be able to move a river, and turn it to ice, there has to be an immense source of power, and Satan is the source. Baffled, Dante asks his guide why this occurs, but Virgil doesn’t deign to respond. He tells Dante that he will see in due time, leaving the mystery alive. They keep on walking. Later, Dante reveals that if Lucifer were to cease beating his wings, escape would be possible.
One question still remains: Why is this circle of hell frozen as opposed to flaming?
No definitive answer can be concluded, but there is a plausible reason. The farther down Dante and Virgil descend into hell, the farther away they become from God. The Father is the ultimate source of light and radiant heat, and the closer we get to Him, the “warmer” we become. Because the sinful refused to accept Jesus and the Father, their warmth vanishes. Satan, being the opposite of the Almighty, radiates ice and darkness.
Because of the sinner’s wicked acts committed during their lives, they have cut themselves off from any sense of humanity and, ultimately, from Christ. The absence of their humanity, which was given to them by the Creator, creates a desolate, frozen wasteland forever encrusted in ice.
Biblically, hell is described as a place of extreme heat and torment. Revelation 21:8 says “they will be consigned to the fiery lake of burning sulfur. This is the second death.”, which introduces the idea of a fiery, sulfurous (rotten) location. Jesus also calls hell a place of “weeping and gnashing of teeth” in Matthew 13:50. However, is the biblical description literal or merely figurative like Dante’s description? Of course, we can never truly know what God meant when he inspired men to write these words and descriptions, but we can come to a simple conclusion: hell is torture.
Dante’s description of hell seems to be focused more on the emotional and spiritual implications of their earthly sins and the punishments that coincide with those sins. Dante chooses to focus on the why and how behind the sins versus the physical ramifications after death. The Bible describes hell in terms of physical punishment and torture.
Whether the torture is in the form of blazing fire as described in the Bible, or as a frozen wasteland as described in Inferno, hell is a place of pure and unforgiving torment. No soul ever wishes to experience the agony of hell, but, ultimately, actions speak louder than words where hell is concerned.